The movies have shown that representation of potentially unpopular or discriminated figures is important. Gregory Peck played the fictional lawyer Atticus Finch in, To Kill a Mockingbird.
One of the most fundamental rights as Americans is to be represented by an attorney in at a trial or hearing. This right was so fundamental, it was included in our cherished Bill of Rights, along with the right to free speech, freedom of religion, and right to bear arms. Our Common Law legal system, being an adversarial legal process, works with each side being allowed (within Court rules) to “fight it out” in court. An impartial jury then renders a verdict through the adversarial process.
Real lawyer Edgar Steele, became known as “attorney for the damned” when he defended Aryan Nations founder Richard Butler. His motto was “equal rights for all, special rights for none”. He defended those maligned and demonized and won their cases. Steele was thought by many falsely accused of a crime, and wound up in prison himself where he died under mysterious circumstances.
If one side has legal counsel and the other does not, Lady Justice’s scales are tipped substantially to the represented side. It’s a reason we appoint legal counsel in criminal cases (and in some civil matters) for those who cannot afford it. The first, and primary, professional ethical rule for lawyers is to “zealously represent the client” and do everything within the ethics rules on behalf of the client.
In America we are (or should be) taught to respect lawyers’ ethical duty of zealous representation, regardless of who is being represented. When that ethic is violated, all other rights are at risk and Justice is not served. With the 2020 elections challenge, and the impeachment trial of Donald Trump, that ethic has come under assault like at no other time in American history and we all must agree to stop it. Let me explain.
First, the 2020 Presidential election challenges were the legitimate right to judicial redress of alleged election illegalities. Despite media hype about “all cases being tossed out in court for lack of evidence”, that just wasn’t what has happened. Of all the election challenges on Trump’s behalf, two thirds (16 of 21) of the cases in which the courts reviewed the evidence (versus being dismissed on procedural grounds) were won by Trump’s side. Cases are still ongoing, and five cases are waiting to be heard by the Supreme Court (the following link is the status of all the hundreds of cases filed in on behalf of Trump’s campaign, including the 17 cases won by Trump’s side.
Real life lawyer Gerry Spence, defended Randy Weaver of Ruby Ridge fame against the Federal Government after they killed his wife and young son. Spence won the case proving they conspired against an American citizen.
Despite the legitimacy, lawyers bringing these suits have been attacked unmercifully. Trump’s lawyers have had to endure withering assaults, not only in the media, but by threats and grievances against their law licenses [see Lin Wood, Rudy Guiliani, Sidney Powell, Michael Van Der Veen, etc]. As one example, the Attorney General Tweeted the following threat against attorneys representing challenges in Michigan: “Fun fact: Lawyers who practice in Michigan are required to take an oath to support the MI and US Constitutions, not to file unjust and/or frivolous actions or mislead the court. The spate of Trump lawsuits in our state violates each of these tenets. It demeans our profession.” She posted the code of professional ethics to further elaborate her threat. Interestingly, that same Attorney General tried to fight against the forensic audit of Antrim County voting machines, which turned out to have an exponentially higher ballot rejection rate than required. She also failed to investigate after the many sworn statements to suspected ballots arriving (by van) to the main counting center in MI around eight hours voting ended. Through Freedom of Information Act requests, the video of the Nov 4, 3:30 am white van was released in February, 2021.
Kirk Lyons is another real life lawyer who defends those who have been demonized or who may be unpopular. Lyons defended the Branch Davidians of Waco, Texas after their leader David Koresh was accused of child abuse. The Davidians were subsequently targeted and firebombed by the Federal Government where 76 people were burned alive with incendiary devices launched by the BATF and FBI.
When Donald Trump began looking for attorneys to represent him in his impeachment trial, he ran into the results of the threats against lawyers taking his cases. From Bloomberg News: “Another reason for good lawyers remaining on the sidelines is the pressure being applied to law firms by interest groups such as the Lincoln Project, said Jonathan Turley, a constitutional-law professor at George Washington University Law School. Just days after the election was called for Biden, elite law firms such as Jones Day were being publicly berated for filing election challenges on behalf of Trump. ‘The harassment and doxing of lawyers has been unprecedented,’ Turley said. ‘What’s most concerning is that groups like the Lincoln Project have been funded heavily by lawyers who have supported the targeting of bar members for representing the president. It will be difficult for the president to assemble the legal team because of that intimidating environment.’ Big law firms admitted they would not allow associates to take elections challenge cases on Trump’s defense. Trump finally settled on three attorneys who were independent from big firms and willing to face the consequences.
Despite the advantage of the House Managers over the tiny and unprepared Trump team, they sent over their evidence only after they had started their arguments with the evidence. This gave the Trump team only a few hours to review, and became the equivalent of a legal “ambush”. The Trump team later discovered that the House Managers had doctored evidence, including the changing of years on Tweets, doctored marking of Tweets, and editing videos. The Trump team ultimately won acquittal for their client, but paid a huge price for their “underdog” representation. According to Trump Attorney Michael van der Veen, when asked about the consequences: “My home was attacked. I’d rather not go into it because it would encourage other people to do it more, but you know, I’ve had nearly 100 death threats… My home was attacked last night — windows broken, spray paint, really bad words spray-painted everywhere.” This included someone spray-painting the word “traitor” on van der Veen’s driveway, which was in a residential section of Philadelphia. He also mentioned that his practice was “under siege”.
A photo from the Branch Davidian siege in April 1993 by the Federal government. The Davidians were accused of child abuse but leader David Koresh was regularly in town prior to being labeled, demonized and ultimately the entire group being firebombed.
The media not only didn’t help Trump’s lawyers by discouraging the harassment, the day after this story broke, CNN ran a story reminiscent of the Threats of the Michigan Attorney General: “There May be Penalties for Trump’s Lawyers, and Here’s Why”. In that story by CNN’s John Avlon, he alleged that Trump’s lawyers put forth falsehoods during the impeachment trial, like repeating Trump’s alleged false claims of elections fraud. Avlon argued that Trump’s lawyers violated Pennsylvania’s rules of professional conduct and put the attorneys at risk of punitive sanctions. Ironically, Avlon said about the doctoring of evidence by the House Manager Attorneys. During the Trial, van der Veen had lamented the threats by a group of law professors who claimed that van der Veen’s First Amendment arguments were “legally frivolous”, and therefore could result in punitive sanctions against Trump’s lawyers for making frivolous arguments. In publicizing these alleged unethical conduct of Trump’s lawyers, they are telling millions how to make a grievance against them, and harm the lawyers’ careers. Clearly a message to other lawyers.
These threats and harassment against conservative lawyers for representing clients is dangerous. Throughout history, we have praised the bold attorney willing to take an unpopular cause, like Atticus Finch in “To Kill A Mockingbird”. That’s for the simple reason we all want our fair day in court if accused. By stripping away representation through threats against attorneys, both justice and freedom are undermined in the gravest of ways. People become afraid to exercise rights that might be considered unpopular by a certain group, for fear of unjust and unfair prosecution. Those in power are able to crush opposing political parties or views, and those in the crosshairs will be alone in court. With the coinciding attacks on free speech, Liberty is under siege like never before. It’s up to all of us, from all political persuasions, to demand that when it comes to our Courts we all get the same chance for justice. God Bless America!
Bill Connor, is an Orangeburg, S.C. attorney, Army Infantry Colonel and author of the book “Articles from War.”
Please “like”, comment, share with a friend, and donate to support The Standard on this page. Become a Patron!
Independent journalism is more critical than ever at this time in our country when it seems the dominant media has taken control of the national and local narrative with a leftist agenda. When you support The Standard, you support independent media and freedom of the press at a time when all our Liberties are under attack! Join us now and support freedom of the press! Would you click the donation button now? You can help get critical information into the hands of your friends and neighbors for as little as $1 a month! A monthly donation of $25, $100, $500 or more, helps alert local churches, businesses, and others in our community of the pending dangers confronting us and are heading our way. Please help us ring the bell of truth and Liberty today and make a donation to The Standard!
RSS - Posts